D&D illogic

[zevonian]

How much logic can one expect from any rpg system that offers the Wish spell?

[Classic Gamer]

What if you wish for a logical explanation?

[Astra]

Originally Posted by Classic Gamer

What if you wish for a logical explanation?

I think when that happens the DM declares the campaign over and you start rolling up some level 1s.

[zevonian]

The GM grants the wish by having a really smart wizard, complete with a pointy wizard's hat, appear to talk to the party. But since you didn't specify what you wanted to have logically explained, you get a clear presentation on something that doesn't much pertain to the plot, such as how the hat was crafted.