[Information] General Feedback!

[hvg3akaek]

Thanks for sitting (or standing?) through this competition!

In an effort to make next year's competition even better, we're asking for your feedback - let us know what you liked, what you thought didn't work, and what you would like to see next year.

Feel free to secret your ideas, and to be as specific or as general as you would like.

Thanks!

[GodRosen]

[Bhelogan]

[moozuba]

[Avner]

[Rolzup]

No secrets here: I'm already of two minds about this one.

Part of me would like to see less "silly" ingredients. They can lead to a very jarring tone to an entry, particularly when it's something really anachronistic.

On the other hand, isn't that part of the whole "challenge" thing? And aren't I just an old curmudgeon who hates fun? Hopefully not the latter, although I don't doubt that my kids would argue otherwise....

But it's really the only thing that comes to mind regarding last year's competition.

[moozuba]

I've made comments above, but here's what still sticks with me after half a year or so.

[GodRosen]

Here is what has stuck with me since it ended.

[Inem]

Thanks for the additional poke to give feedback, I meant to back when the competition ended and somehow never got around to doing it until it was no longer on my mind...

[Jarl11]

[PIG]

Originally Posted by Rolzup

Part of me would like to see less "silly" ingredients.

I'm in full agreement on this one. I can take the competition more seriously if it takes its self more serious.

[Raylorne]

<Placeholder for future brilliance>

hvg3: no, don't do that! If you edit it, I won't see a "new post" come up, and thus won't look back, and thus will miss the brilliance! Just post again

[Brainfist]